Index | Parent Index | Build Freedom: Archive

Economic Means to Freedom - Part V (Appendices 3 and 4)

Appendix 3 - RIEGEL vs. GOLD

by Frederick Mann, Revised 10/2/98

[Note: This article was originally published on 11/4/97 as "Alternative Currency System." It has been extensively revised.]

For an example of gold-based monetary system, see http://www.e-gold.com/.

Private gold-based monetary systems certainly have an important role to play in shifting economic power from coercive political agencies into the hands of private individuals.

I propose that creating, in addition to gold-based systems, sound private fiat money systems, will further increase the shift of economic power from coercive political agencies into the hands of private individuals. I suggest that we need both gold-based and sound private fiat money systems.

The following articles provide critical perspectives of gold and gold as money:

Silver Threads & Golden Needles -- http://investingcanada.about.com/library/weekly/1998/aa040698.htm.

All That Glitters: Part 1 -- http://investingcanada.about.com/library/weekly/1997/aa111197.htm (links to gold sites).

All That Glitters: Part 2 -- http://investingcanada.about.com/library/weekly/1997/aa111897.htm.

All That Glitters: Part 3 -- http://investingcanada.about.com/library/weekly/1997/aa120297.htm.

See Appendix 2 for links to other alternative currency/money systems.

Advantages of the Riegel System
(a) As E.C. Riegel pointed out in Appendix 1, the individual power to issue money is a most awesome power. A gold-based system does not enable this power to be exercised. The Riegel system does. If the Riegel system can be successfully developed, implemented, and launched, it will bring about a much greater shift of economic power into the hands of private individuals than any gold-based system.

(b) Competing gold-based (and other) monetary systems in a free or relatively free market will help to ensure the integrity of the Riegel. Coercive political agencies can to some extent protect themselves against some of the consequences of inflating their currencies by making them "legal tender," forcing their victims to accept and use their currencies. In a free market this "luxury" isn't available. Hence the controllers of the Riegel system are more likely to maintain the integrity of their money.

(c) In a gold-based system, total economic activity is to some extent limited by the total quantity of gold owned by the members of the system. With the Riegel system there is no such limitation. Thus the Riegel system is likely to bring about a greater degree of economic activity -- resulting in more wealth creation -- than a gold-based system.

(d) Coercive political agencies (and banksters in bed with them) own a great deal of gold, which they can use for manipulative purposes. For example, they can at any time dump large quantities of gold on the market, effectively hurting the purchasing power of private gold owners. Coercive political agencies don't own any Riegels and probably should never be allowed to own Riegels. (Conceivably, Riegels could be used to persuade terrocrats (coercive political agents or terrorist bureaucrats) to relinquish their coercive practices, i.e. "go straight." Gold cannot be used in this respect.)

(e) Gold is subject to confiscation -- as has happened in the past. The Riegel, not being physical, is far more difficult to confiscate.

(f) Apart from the increased personal empowerment individuals gain from activating their personal money-issuing power, members of the Riegel economy are more likely to gain a deeper understanding of money, particularly if they study E.C. Riegel's Private Enterprise Money at http://www.mind-trek.com/treatise/ecr-pem/index.htm.

Appendix 4 - RIEGEL REFERENCE VALUE

I have three suggestions for defining a "reference value" for the Riegel: (a) One Riegel = U.S. Consumer Price Index / 160; (b) One Riegel = Commodity Research Bureau Index / 200; (c) One Riegel = Basket of Commodities / 1,000,000.

In the first case, the Riegel reference value is defined more or less as a constant function of the products and services a typical family buys every month. In the last two cases, the Riegel reference value is defined in terms of basic commodities. When using the CRB Index, the Riegel is effectively defined as a function of the commodities that constitute the CRB Index. When defined in terms of the suggested basket of commodities below, the Riegel reference value is defined in terms of the specific commodities in the quantities I suggest.

(a) RIEGEL DEFINED IN TERMS OF US CONSUMER PRICE INDEX

The CPI can be found at http://www.ctdol.state.ct.us/lmi/misc/cpius.htm.


Consumer Price Index

Year Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Annual
Ave.
% Chg
1990 127.4  128.0  128.7  128.9  129.2  129.9  130.4  131.6  132.7  133.5  133.8  133.8  130.7  5.4%
91 134.6  134.8  135.0  135.2  135.6  136.0  136.2  136.6  137.2  137.4  137.8  137.9  136.2  4.2%
92 138.1  138.6  139.3  139.5  139.7  140.2  140.5  140.9  141.3  141.8  142.0  141.9  140.3  3.0%
93 142.6  143.1  143.6  144.0  144.2  144.4  144.4  144.8  145.1  145.7  145.8  145.8  144.5  3.0%
94 146.2  146.7  147.2  147.4  147.5  148.0  148.4  149.0  149.4  149.5  149.7  149.7  148.2  2.6%
95 150.3  150.9  151.4  151.9  152.2  152.5  152.5  152.9  153.2  153.7  153.6  153.5  152.4  2.8%
96 154.4  154.9  155.7  156.3  156.6  156.7  157.0  157.3  157.8  158.3  158.6  158.6  156.9  3.0%
97 159.1  159.6  160.0  160.2  160.1  160.3  160.5  160.8  161.2  161.6  161.5  161.3  160.5  2.3%
98 161.6  161.9  162.2  162.5
% Chg 1.6% 1.4% 1.4% 1.4%

We can think of the CPI as representing an index of all the things the typical family buys and pays for during a month, expressed in US$s.

We could define the reference value of the Riegel as CPI / 160. This would mean that the reference value of the Riegel more or less remains a constant function of what people typically buy.

Because over the long term the dollar tends to be inflated on a continuous basis (the supply of dollars grows faster than the quantity of products and services people typically buy), the dollar gradually loses its purchasing power and the CPI goes up.

Jan 98: One Riegel = 161.6 / 160 = $1.0100
Feb 98: One Riegel = 161.9 / 160 = $1.0119
Mar 98: One Riegel = 162.2 / 160 = $1.0138
Apr 98: One Riegel = 162.5 / 160 = $1.0156

Note that the above doesn't represent exchange rates between the Rgl and the $. I'm essentially defining an agreed-upon reference value for the Riegel. The actual exchange rate in the market will fluctuate according to supply and demand and other factors. But the reference value of the Riegel is being held more or less as a constant representing what people typically buy.

(b) RIEGEL DEFINED IN TERMS OF CRB INDEX

The simplest "commodity definition" would be in terms of the CRB Index. I suggest that the price of the nearest futures contract be used. The reference value of the Riegel can be defined as one two-hundredth of the commodities that constitute the CRB Index.

Commodity Research Bureau Index (Sep, 1996) = 243.40 One Riegel = $1.217

Commodity Research Bureau Index (Nov, 1997) = 242.70 Percentage decline of CRB Index since Sep, 1996 = 0.288% One Riegel = $1.2135

Commodity Research Bureau Index (Jan, 1998) = 236.00 Percentage decline of CRB Index since Sep, 1996 = 3.040% One Riegel = $1.18

Commodity Research Bureau Index (Jun, 1998) = 214.00 Percentage decline of CRB Index since Sep, 1996 = 12.079% One Riegel = $1.07

Note that the reference value of the Riegel relative to the US$ drops when commodity prices decline, and vice versa.

The disadvantage of the CRB Index definition is that it's unrealistic. The typical family doesn't buy these basic commodities. They buy manufactured products and services.

(c) RIEGEL DEFINED IN TERMS OF A "BASKET OF COMMODITIES"

The reference value of the Riegel could be defined in terms of the basket of commodities below.


Based on closing prices of nearest month, actively traded futures contract prices - Aug 2, 1996

Cattle 100,000 lbs 0.669/lb 66,900.00
Cocoa 20 metric tons 1,345/ton 26,900.00
Coffee 40,000 lbs 1.075/lb 43,000.00
Copper 100,000 lbs 0.918/lb 91,800.00
Corn 20,000 bushels 3.5825/bu 71,650.00
Cotton 40,000 lbs 0.7229/lb 28,916.00
Heating Oil 40,000 gal 0.5871/gal 23,484.00
Hogs 40,000  lbs 0.5972/lb 23,888.00
Lumber 200,000 bd ft 0.3576/bd ft 71,520.00
Natural Gas 20,000 mm BTU 2.315/mm BTU 46,300.00
Oil, L/S Crude 4,000 bbl 21.34/bbl 85,360.00
Orange Juice 20,000 lbs 1.119/lb 22,380.00
Palladium 100 troy oz 129.75/troy oz 12,975.00
Platinum 100 troy oz 407.4/troy oz 40,740.00
Rough Rice 500,000 lbs 0.10565/lb 52,825.00
Silver 4,000troy oz 5.075/troy oz 20,300.00
Soybeans 4,000 bushels 7.7275/bu 30,910.00
Soybean Meal 40 tons 244.1/ton 9,764.00
Soybean Oil 40,000 lbs 0.2429/lb 9,716.00
Sugar 600,000 lbs 0.1171/lb 70,260.00
Unleaded Gas 100,000 gal 0.6212/gal 62,120.00
Wheat 20,000 bushels 4.49/bu 89,800.00
---------------------
$1,001,508.00

1,000,000 Riegel = value of total commodities in basket.

1 Riegel = Basket / 1,000,000 = $1.001508 on Aug 2, 1996


Based on closing prices of nearest month, actively traded futures contract prices - Nov 11, 1997

Cattle 100,000 lbs 0.6657/lb 66,570.00 -
Cocoa 20 metric tons 1,621/ton 32,420.00 +
Coffee 40,000 lbs 1.5625/lb 62,500.00 +
Copper 100,000 lbs 0.891/lb 89,100.00 -
Corn 20,000 bushels 2.765/bu 55,300.00 -
Cotton 40,000 lbs 0.7033/lb 28,132.00 -
Heating Oil 40,000 gal 0.5782/gal 23,128.00 -
Hogs 40,000 lbs 0.616/lb 24,640.00 +
Lumber 200,000 bd ft 0.2989/bd ft 59,780.00 -
Natural Gas 20,000 mm BTU 3.495/mm BTU 69,900.00 +
Oil, L/S Crude 4,000 bbl 20.51/bbl 82,040.00 -
Orange Juice 20,000 lbs 0.8125/lb 16,250.00 -
Palladium 100 troy oz 208.35/troy oz 20,835.00 +
Platinum 100 troy oz 389.3/troy oz 38,930.00 -
Rough Rice 500,000 lbs 0.1064/lb 53,200.00 +
Silver 4,000 troy oz 4.82/troy oz 19,280.00 -
Soybeans 4,000 bushels 7.3775/bu 29,510.00 -
Soybean Meal 40 tons 241.9/ton 9,676.00 -
Soybean Oil 40,000 lbs 0.2609/lb 10,436.00 +
Sugar 600,000 lbs 0.1235/lb 74,100.00 +
Unleaded Gas 100,000 gal 0.5906/gal 59,060.00 -
Wheat 20,000 bushels 3.495/bu 69,900.00 -
------------------
$994,687.00

1,000,000 Riegel = value of total commodities in basket.

1 Riegel = Basket / 1,000,000 = $0.994687 on Nov 11, 1997

Percentage decline of Riegel against US$ since Aug 2, 1996 = 0.681%


Based on closing prices of nearest month, actively traded futures contract prices - Dec 5, 1997

Cattle 100,000 lbs 0.6742/lb 67,420.00 +
Cocoa 20 metric tons 1,581/ton 31,620.00 -
Coffee 40,000 lbs 1.7895/lb 71,580.00 +
Copper 100,000 lbs 0.796/lb 79,600.00 -
Corn 20,000 bushels 2.69/bu 53,800.00 -
Cotton 40,000 lbs 0.6686/lb 26,744.00 -
Heating Oil 40,000 gal 0.5338/gal 21,352.00 -
Hogs 40,000 lbs 0.63/lb 25,200.00 +
Lumber 200,000 bd ft 0.3141/bd ft 62,820.00 +
Natural Gas 20,000 mm BTU 2.452/mm BTU 49,040.00 -
Oil, L/S Crude 4,000 bbl 18.71/bbl 74,840.00 -
Orange Juice 20,000 lbs 0.805/lb 16,100.00 -
Palladium 100 troy oz 209.65/troy oz 20,965.00 +
Platinum 100 troy oz 381/troy oz 38,100.00 -
Rough Rice 500,000 lbs 0.1059/lb 52,950.00 -
Silver 4,000 troy oz 5.365/troy oz 21,460.00 +
Soybeans 4,000 bushels 7.0325/bu 28,130.00 -
Soybean Meal 40 tons 231.5/ton 9,260.00 -
Soybean Oil 40,000 lbs 0.2468/lb 9,872.00 -
Sugar 600,000 lbs 0.1244/lb 74,640.00 +
Unleaded Gas 100,000 gal 0.5659/gal 56,590.00 -
Wheat 20,000 bushels 3.44/bu 68,800.00 -
------------------
$960,883.00

1,000,000 Riegel = value of total commodities in basket.

1 Riegel = Basket / 1,000,000 = $0.960523 on Dec 5, 1997

Percentage decline of Riegel against US$ since Aug 2, 1996 = 4.056%


Based on closing prices of nearest month, actively traded futures contract prices - Jun 5, 1998

Cattle 100,000 lbs 0.6452/lb 64,520.00 -
Cocoa 20 metric tons 1,600/ton 32,000.00 +
Coffee 40,000 lbs 1.256/lb 50,240.00 -
Copper 100,000 lbs 0.785/lb 78,500.00 -
Corn 20,000 bushels 2.37/bu 47,400.00 -
Cotton 40,000 lbs 0.7327/lb 29,308.00 +
Heating Oil 40,000 gal 0.3933/gal 15,732.00 -
Hogs 40,000 lbs 0.6252/lb 25,008.00 -
Lumber 200,000 bd ft 0.2842/bd ft 56,840.00 -
Natural Gas 20,000 mm BTU 2.027/mm BTU 40,540.00 -
Oil, L/S Crude 4,000 bbl 15.07/bbl 60,280.00 -
Orange Juice 20,000 lbs 1.0375/lb 20,750.00 +
Palladium 100 troy oz 297/troy oz 29,700.00 +
Platinum 100 troy oz 359.9/troy oz 35,990.00 -
Rough Rice 500,000 lbs 0.1066/lb 53,300.00 +
Silver 4,000 troy oz 5.273/troy oz 21,092.00 -
Soybeans 4,000 bushels 6.1625/bu 24,650.00 -
Soybean Meal 40 tons 154.7/ton 6,188.00 -
Soybean Oil 40,000 lbs 0.2564/lb 10,256.00 +
Sugar 600,000 lbs 0.0807/lb 48,420.00 -
Unleaded Gas 100,000 gal 0.4956/gal 49,560.00 -
Wheat 20,000 bushels 2.80125/bu 56,025.00 -
------------------
$856,299.00

1,000,000 Riegel = value of total commodities in basket.

1 Riegel = Basket / 1,000,000 = $0.856299 on Jun 5, 1998

Percentage decline of Riegel against US$ since Aug 2, 1996 = 14.499%

Click here to read Appendix 5

Index | Parent Index | Build Freedom: Archive

Disclaimer - Copyright - Contact

Online: buildfreedom.org - terrorcrat.com - mind-trek.com